CARRARA TREATMENT / ADDICTION EXPERTS
Flow state is a discrete psychological condition — characterized by complete absorption in a challenging task, effortless focus, and a suspension of self-consciousness — that elite athletes and high performers enter when challenge precisely matches skill. In this episode of We’re Out of Time, host Richard Taite sits down with Dr. Mark Aoyagi, PhD, one of the country’s leading sports and performance psychologists, to explore what separates those who rise under pressure from those who collapse — and why the same personality architecture that produces excellence also produces addiction.
Dr. Aoyagi is Co-Director of Sport and Performance Psychology at the University of Denver Graduate School of Professional Psychology, founder of the Center for Performance Excellence, and a Certified Mental Performance Consultant (CMPC) through the Association for Applied Sport Psychology. He is a licensed psychologist in the state of Colorado, listed on the USOC Sport Psychology Registry, and a Fellow of both the American Psychological Association and the AASP. His clients include the Denver Nuggets, Denver Broncos, Los Angeles Dodgers, and Olympic athletes across multiple disciplines. He is the co-author of Expert Approaches to Sport Psychology and The Peer Guide to Applied Sport Psychology.
The conversation covers the neuroscience of choking, the challenge-skill balance that unlocks flow, why confidence is an action rather than a feeling, and the striking overlap between high-performer psychology and addiction-prone personality profiles. For anyone treating — or navigating — addiction, this episode reframes the internal drives behind substance use not as weakness but as the shadow side of elite human wiring.
Dr. Mark Aoyagi opens with a deceptively simple argument: the performers who hold up under pressure are not those who fear it least — they are those who have earned the right to be in that situation. Aoyagi distinguishes between confidence as a feeling, which is how most coaches and self-help frameworks describe it, and confidence as an action: showing up exactly as you are, with full knowledge that the preparation is real. He uses the example of a high-stakes golf putt — the same mechanical shot becomes nearly impossible when a player’s self-worth is tied to the outcome, and far more makeable when identity is grounded in something larger than the result. For addiction treatment, this framework is clinically meaningful: many people in recovery have never experienced earned confidence because their performance identity was built on external validation rather than internal self-knowledge. Rebuilding that foundation — learning who you are apart from what you accomplish — is a prerequisite for sustainable recovery.
“Pressure is a privilege. You've earned the right to be there.”
Dr. Aoyagi describes flow — the psychological state first systematically mapped by Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi — as a product of a specific environmental condition: a challenge that sits just at the edge of a person’s skill level, neither so easy it produces boredom nor so difficult it produces frustration. Within that challenge-skill balance, combined with clear goals and an absorption in the task, the brain drops into a state of effortless, self-forgetful focus. Aoyagi explains that high-consequence environments — like Alex Honnold free-soloing El Capitan without ropes — force flow by demanding complete engagement: the margin for distraction is zero. The addiction recovery connection is not metaphorical. Neurobiologically, flow and substance intoxication share reward-pathway activation. High performers who lose access to flow — through injury, retirement, or burnout — often find substances filling the same neurological role. Understanding this dynamic explains why performance-oriented patients need a recovery program that offers genuine absorption and challenge, not merely the removal of substances.
One of Dr. Aoyagi’s most clinically relevant frameworks in the episode is the distinction between mental strength — the ability to push through adversity — and mental flexibility, which is the capacity to adapt the approach when the current one is not working. Elite performers are selected precisely for mental strength, which produces drive, persistence, and the willingness to suffer. But over-indexing on mental strength without flexibility creates psychological rigidity: one path to the goal, one definition of success, one identity structure. This rigidity, Aoyagi notes, maps directly onto the perfectionism, obsessive thinking, and compulsive behavior that characterize both elite performance and substance use disorder. He argues that the same cognitive inflexibility that makes an athlete refuse to lose makes a person in addiction refuse to stop — the same fuel, pointed in a different direction. Treatment programs that build mental flexibility alongside sobriety work address something the field typically overlooks: not the substance, but the rigidity that made it necessary.
“Mental toughness says run through the wall. Mental flexibility says, coach, what about this door over here?”
In the episode’s most direct passage connecting sports psychology to addiction treatment, Dr. Aoyagi lists the psychological characteristics that define elite performers — anxiety, perfectionism, rigidity, obsessive thinking and compulsive action, and a degree of narcissism, meaning a belief that one is uniquely capable of achieving something — and asks Richard Taite whether that profile maps onto the people he sees entering addiction treatment. Taite’s response: all of it. Aoyagi’s framing is non-pathologizing and clinically useful: these are not defects. They are the same traits that produce extraordinary output. The personality that drives someone to train at 4 AM and push past every physical limit is structurally identical, in Aoyagi’s view, to the personality that drives compulsive substance use. The directionality changes; the engine does not. For clinicians, this reframe has practical implications: it shifts the goal from eliminating drive to redirecting it, and from managing symptoms to understanding the psychological architecture underneath them.
“The same characteristics, the same personality types that are driven to elite performance are the same ones that are driven to elite substance use.”
Dr. Aoyagi describes the reframe he uses with minor league baseball players around failure: failure is not an unwanted outcome, it is a failure of process. A player who steps in with a plan, commits to it, executes it, and strikes out has not failed. A player who abandons the plan mid-at-bat and happens to hit a home run has failed by process, regardless of the result. This distinction has direct clinical applicability in addiction recovery. Many people in recovery carry an outcome-based definition of failure that makes any setback catastrophic to identity. A process-based framework shifts the question from did I stay sober to did I adhere to the values and behaviors that define who I want to be. Aoyagi’s formulation — taking the next right action, then the next, with full commitment, as the measure of success — maps precisely onto evidence-based relapse prevention and values-clarification work in addiction treatment. Consult a clinician to explore how this framework can support recovery.
The psychological literature on performance excellence and addiction has historically developed in parallel silos — sports psychology on one side, addiction medicine on the other. The convergence that Dr. Aoyagi describes in this episode is increasingly supported by research. A 2018 review published in the Journal of Clinical Sport Psychology identified perfectionism, high need for achievement, anxiety sensitivity, and compulsive behavioral tendencies as shared trait predictors of both elite athletic performance and elevated substance use risk. The profile is not coincidental — it reflects a common underlying temperament that manifests differently depending on the environment and the available outlet.
Flow, the psychological state first systematically described by Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi, has been documented as intrinsically rewarding — activating dopaminergic reward circuitry in ways structurally similar to the reward response produced by substances of abuse. Research published in Psychological Science suggests that the challenge-skill balance that produces flow also produces a reliable neurochemical payoff: focused effort at the edge of one’s capability triggers dopamine release, creating a self-reinforcing loop of engagement. For high performers who lose access to that loop — through injury, retirement, burnout, or the natural ceiling of their sport — the neurobiological craving for that reward state does not disappear. Substances provide a pharmacological shortcut to a biochemically similar destination, which helps explain why elite athletic identity and substance use disorder so frequently co-occur in clinical populations.
Dr. Aoyagi’s clinical framework maps directly onto the identity disruption that addiction treatment teams encounter in high-functioning patients. Athletes and executives who enter treatment often carry a rigidly performance-defined sense of self — what they do, not who they are. The loss of that performance identity, whether through retirement, professional failure, or the collapse that precedes treatment-seeking, removes the primary structure through which they have organized meaning and self-worth. Without an alternative values-based identity, the absence is intolerable. Dr. Aoyagi’s work on values clarification and self-discovery provides a clinical parallel to what the addiction field calls meaning-making — and both point to the same necessary work.
PhD - Co-Director, Sport and Performance Psychology; Certified Mental Performance Consultant (CMPC)
University of Denver Graduate School of Professional Psychology
Dr. Mark Aoyagi, PhD is a licensed psychologist and Co-Director of Sport and Performance Psychology at the University of Denver Graduate School of Professional Psychology, where he also founded the Center for Performance Excellence. He is a Certified Mental Performance Consultant (CMPC) through the Association for Applied Sport Psychology and is listed on the USOC Sport Psychology Registry. A Fellow of both the American Psychological Association and the AASP, Dr. Aoyagi has worked with professional and Olympic athletes across multiple sports, including the Denver Nuggets, Denver Broncos, Los Angeles Dodgers, and USA Track and Field. His clinical and consulting work focuses on performance excellence, team effectiveness, identity development, and the meaning athletes derive from sport and life. He is the co-author of Expert Approaches to Sport Psychology and The Peer Guide to Applied Sport Psychology. Dr. Aoyagi holds a doctorate from the University of Denver and maintains active licensure in Colorado.
CONFIDENTIAL CONSULTATION
Take the First Step
Carrara Treatment, Wellness & Spa offers personalized care. Consult a clinician to explore your options.
(888) 383-5207Contact UsFEATURED GUEST
Dr. Mark Aoyagi
PhD
Two Carrara Treatment psychiatrists — Dr. Ben Shapiro and Dr. Brett Shurman — break down the neuroscience of addiction, the fentanyl crisis, TMS therapy, and why treating the whole person is the only path to durable recovery.
Veteran interventionist Candy Finnigan — 32 years, hundreds of cases, A&E’s Intervention — explains how families unknowingly sustain addiction, why love isn’t enough, and what actually moves someone toward treatment.
Dr. Wendy Walsh, PhD explains the science of love, attachment styles, and why anxious attachment is a primary driver of substance use disorders and addiction.
Clinical neuropsychologist Dr. Daniel Hai explains why the brain can change at any age, why therapeutic labels can hinder healing, and how neurocognitive therapy blends neuroscience, attachment, and real-world exposure to produce lasting recovery.
Psychologist and TED speaker Dr. Guy Winch explains why emotional wounds from rejection and loneliness are as damaging as physical injuries — and why treating them is the missing piece in addiction recovery.
Happiness researcher Dr. Sonja Lyubomirsky explains why people in good circumstances still feel empty, how hedonic adaptation erases joy, and what evidence-based practices actually build lasting wellbeing — including for people in addiction recovery.
Carrara Treatment, Wellness & Spa offers personalized care. Consult a clinician to explore your options.
